Summary report on establishment meetings for the LSSA provincial attorneys’ associations

The Law Society of South Africa (LSSA) has held eight meetings regarding the establishment of provincial attorneys’ associations around the country. These took place at the following places:

• East London: 2 October 2019 (and follow up meeting on 6 November 2019)
• Limpopo: 24 October 2019
• Bloemfontein: 25 October 2019
• Nelspruit: 29 October 2019
• Kimberley: 31 October 2019
• Durban: 14 November 2019
• Cape Town: 20 November 2019

The only province that the LSSA could not hold a meeting at was the North West as the attendance confirmation number was too low. This meeting has been postponed to a date still to be confirmed, in January next year.

The LSSA was given a good reception at almost all the provinces. The LSSA was able to get buy-in from the attorneys present for the establishment of LSSA provincial attorneys associations due to the general views expressed that it was important to be affiliated to an established and recognised body such as the LSSA, noting that as the LSSA constituent bodies make up just a fraction of the total number of attorneys in the country.

Out of the nine provinces, seven have endorsed the LSSA provincial attorneys associations. The LSSA resolved to allow the Limpopo attorneys time to meet and to deliberate, and to hold another meeting with them in early 2020.

One of the questions that was repeatedly asked was whether membership to the LSSA attorneys associations was open to advocates. The LSSA responded by advising, that as far as representing advocates was concerned, the LSSA had been formed for attorneys. Advocates had the General Council of the Bar and other Bar Councils. It had always been an objective of the LSSA and its constituent members to have one professional interest body for all legal practitioners – advocates and attorneys. However, the Legal Practice Act made a distinction between advocates and attorneys and at this stage it was important to organise the attorneys under the umbrella of the LSSA.

The LSSA was an established institution. The intention was to build on what it had. In the future advocates with fidelity fund certificates would be included. The LSSA noted that the LPC regulated the profession as a unified body, but in practice, attorneys and advocates were regulated differently in terms of the LPA. It was also resolved that as attorneys, we would organise ourselves first, then invite the advocates at a later stage.

It should also be noted that at almost all the provinces, what was unanimous was that attorneys want to be part of the provincial structures of the LSSA. They all brought up the issue of governance whereby the LSSA advised that it would not force governance structures upon them, however, any governance structure needed to mirror the national structure (LSSA).

After a few meetings and deliberation with the Gauteng Attorneys Association (GAA), the LSSA formally welcomed the first LSSA Provincial Attorneys Association to its ranks and issued a press release and advisory by its President, Mvuzo Notyesi, informing legal practitioners of this historic occasion on Friday 1 November 2019.

The GAA and the LSSA agreed that the GAA would now be referred to as the the Gauteng Attorneys Association of the Law Society of South Africa and that the chairperson of the GAA, Ms Chantelle Gladwin-Wood will chair the new provincial association. The new association will also have a representative on the LSSA House of Constituents and will participate fully in all the functions and activities of the LSSA.

Eastern Cape
The members agreed in principle to establish an Eastern Cape Attorneys Association of the LSSA. An interim structure comprising of members drawn from the eight circles in the EC will be established. The local circle will be tasked to nominate three people from its city, not necessarily circle members but people that are willing to do the work. A deadline for convening the interim committee and the drafting of a constitution will be established once the task team is formed so that there is ample time to consider the constitution.

The eight attorneys’ circles in the Eastern Cape are:
• Transkei
• Butterworth
• East London and Mdantsane
• Port Elizabeth
• Queenstown
• Grahamstown
• Humansdorp/Kouga
• King Williams Town

All the circles were tasked to nominate three people to sit on the task team. The task team will develop the constitution. The three nominees from each circle will be from the BLA, NADEL and from the non-BLA and non-NADEL members. East London and Mdantsane was nominated as the convenor because of its central positioning in the Eastern Cape.

The LSSA School for Legal Practice will assist the task team in convening its meetings in terms of venue etc. There will be 24 members in total on the task team. The 24 will oversee the elective process for the executive structure and will oversee the new constitution and that is in line with the LSSA one.

The LSSA requested that at least 12 of the 24 be female practitioners. Communication was sent out to the secretariat of the eight structures informing them of the position taken at the meeting and to request for the names of the task team members by Friday 6 December 2019.

The task team will report to the LSSA and must produce a constitution by a deadline determined by the LSSA. The association should be formally established by no later than February 2020.

The LSSA will hold another meeting in Polokwane in early 2020 as members asked for additional time to discuss among themselves.

Free State
It was noted that there was already a task team that was established that was waiting on the finalisation of the LSSA’s constitution amendment in regard to the LSSA provincial attorneys associations. It was resolved that the Free State circles will be combined into the Free State Attorneys Association of the Law Society of South Africa. It was suggested that time frames be set up for the formal establishment. The task team will take the work forward and will see to it that the Free State Attorneys Association of the LSSA is established. The designated chair of the task team will communicate the dates.

There were some advocates that also attended the meeting. Members unanimously agreed to the establishment of the LSSA Provincial attorney’s association for Mpumalanga.

It was agreed that the PC chairperson will liaise with NADEL and BLA structures for names for the establishment of a task team to draw up a constitution, noting it must mirror the governance structure of the LSSA. Some members at the meeting volunteered their services and it was agreed to co-opt them into the task team.

The LSSA also agreed to host an information session on the Highveld and this will be scheduled in Middelburg, although this will not stop the work of the task team in drafting a constitution.

Northern Cape
In the Northern Cape, an attorneys’ association had already been established – the Northern Cape Attorneys’ Association (NCAA). However, the LSSA agreed not recognise the association, as its governance structure did not comply with the LSSA’s constitution. Nevertheless, it was resolved that there should be a basis for the LSSA and the NCAA to find a solution.

It was agreed that an association be established. The existing Northern Cape Attorneys’ Association would consider bringing its constitution in line with the LSSA’s constitution so that there would be no need to form another association. All attorneys should participate in the LSSA Provincial Attorneys Association.

KwaZulu- Natal
It was agreed that there must be a KwaZulu Natal Attorneys Association of the Law Society of South Africa. However, this required a meeting in January or early February to deal with the details of the structures of that organisation and to work on its constitution, noting that the deadline that all LSSA attorneys’ associations must be established by the end of February 2020. A committee was established to start the work. The BLA, NADEL and non-BLA and non-NADEL will nominate two people each and will forward the names to the LSSA, this will be the task team. The task team will be on the ground and will get the ball rolling.

It was suggested that the minutes of the meeting be circulated for benefit of those that were not able to attend to communicate the resolutions adopted. Six names for the task team needed to be submitted to facilitate the establishment of the association. Two names must be submitted from the BLA, NADEL and non-BLA and non-NADEL. The next meeting will be held in the first week of February 2020. It was highlighted that the structures must be established prior to the LSSA AGM in April 2020.

Western Cape
Everyone agreed with the establishment of the association. It was agreed that a task team be formed that will involve the existing circles (with option to co-opt others) as well as the BLA and NADEL. The task team will convene its first meeting to move forward as everyone agreed that the LSSA Provincial Attorneys Association should be established. The names will be submitted to the LSSA.

It was noted that the Western Cape has four associations, namely: Tygerberg, Cape Town, Southern suburbs and Coastal Winelands. The meeting acknowledged the presence of the Overberg association and agreed that they should be invited to send a representative to the task team.
The members should discuss amongst themselves and revert when they were ready but were advised to ensure that this was urgently finalised. A deadline by the latest early February 2020, for the formation of the Provincial Attorneys Association was agreed on.

It was suggested that once the task team was formed, communication be sent to members and to the previous circles informing them of the developments.




Law Society of South Africa supports 16 Days of Activism campaign for No Violence Against Women and Children

The Law Society of South Africa (LSSA) supports the 16 Days of Activism for No Violence Against Women and Children. This international campaign runs annually from 25 November to 10 December and it opposes violence against women and children.

The campaign aims to raise awareness of the negative impact that violence and abuse have on women and children and to rid society of such abuse.

South Africa has a history in the oppression of women. The inequality between men and women in their careers is endemic, the legal profession is no different from the patriarchal environment that practices inequality and the LSSA will continue to work on transforming the profession, including the equality of female lawyers.

The country witnesses the most harrowing violent acts of abuse committed on women and children, more so when it is performed by their loved ones, the very people who are supposed to protect them.

The recent campaign against femicide is part of this campaign, and it is apt to use the slogan in this campaign ‘you must be the change that you wish to see in the world’. All members of our society must join to eradicate this culture, which goes against our humanity and our African values.

‘We call on all citizens to commit to a community free of violence against women and children, beyond the 16 days,’ says LSSA President, Mvuzo Notyesi.

Mr Notyesi adds: ‘The LSSA and its gender committee has been engaging with Legal Aid South Africa to facilitate the involvement of legal practitioners at educational and outreach events aimed at raising public awareness of rights and the legal system in the context of domestic violence, children’s rights and related matters.


LSSA Communications:
Nomfundo Jele Tel: (012) 366 8800 or 072 402 6344

Law Society saddened at death of veteran radio personality Xolani Gwala

The Law Society of South Africa (LSSA) is saddened at the passing of radio presenter Xolani Gwala on 1 November 2019 at the age of 44.

Xolani succumbed to colon cancer after making his diagnosis public in September 2017.

‘Xolani Gwala was a passionate journalist who executed his duties without fear or favour. His insightful take on topical issues earned him the respect of listeners across the country. He had a brilliant mind that kept him on the cutting edge of the media. Xolani made sure that those who occupy positions of power are held accountable and he had a knack of getting his on-air guests to volunteer crucial information by treating them with respect even as he asked them difficult questions. We will miss his voice and his insight’, says LSSA President, Mvuzo Notyesi.

Xolani Gwala was also one of the few journalists who engaged with the LSSA and was vocal on the legal profession’s briefing patterns.

We express our deepest condolences to his family, friends and colleagues.

Unreasonable and unfair increased costs imposed on legal practitioners by regulatory bodies

The Law Society of South Africa (LSSA) is cognisant that the Legal Practice Council (LPC) and the Legal Practitioners Fidelity Fund (LPFF) are the two regulators in South Africa that regulate the legal profession in the public interest.

The LSSA appreciates, understands and respects the statutory functions enjoined to these two bodies in terms of the Legal Practice Act (LPA).

The LSSA’s constitution enshrines the rule of law as one of the key principles which the LSSA is committed to uphold and protect. The LSSA notes the regulatory function is based on the principle of the rule of law and cannot be exercised in a vacuum without consideration of the practitioners which the LPC and the LPFF are enjoined to regulate.

The LSSA is therefore concerned that recent proposals by the regulatory bodies has the potential to negatively impact on legal practitioners and may threaten access to and entry to the legal profession, as an unintended consequence of their proposals, viz.

The LPC in publishing rules that were placed in the recent Government gazette, that set levels of prescribed fees that in the view of the LSSA, as the representative body of the legal profession, is of serious concern in that:
•  The fees were published without engagement with the profession.
•  That the various levels proposed is arbitrary and irrational.
•  That there appears to be no consideration by the LPC of containing its costs or proposed alternative measures, (most law firms are currently implementing stringent cost containment measures, due to the current economic realities in our country).
•  That there is no financial basis provided for the establishment of these exorbitant increases.
•  The punitive amounts proposed for practitioners based on years of service, which is divorced from the economic reality of the practices of these attorneys.
•  That mere establishment of the various proposed levels based on demographics appears to be prejudicial and discriminatory.
•  The increased costs have the potential to negatively impact on some the transformation objectives of the LPA (this responsibility vests on both the regulator and the profession).

The LSSA has resolved to request the LPC not to implement the revised annual levies on law firms and practitioners, subject to engagement and agreed consensus with the LSSA on the levels of annual levies.

The LSSA therefore calls for urgent engagement with the LPC and has been requesting a meeting for some time now, with no commitment from the LPC to meet with the LSSA to deal with serious issues facing the profession.

The LSSA as a key stakeholder is willing and committed to engage on the various issues and seek resolution, as the legitimate body representing the attorneys’ profession and the LSSA will consider all remedies available to protect the interest of its members.

 The LSSA reminds all members to vociferously make their voices heard and their concerns known to the LPC and the public and to lodge these by 4 of November 2019, in terms of the notice placed in the Gazette by the LPC.

The LPFF has concomitantly also announced plans to levy legal practitioners for professional indemnity insurance, this is currently provided by the Legal Practitioners Insurance Indemnity Fund (LPIIF), of which the LPFF is the sole shareholder.
The estimate cost of PI insurance will eventually rise to above R10 000 p.a.
Similarly, this will also negatively impact on the cost of the profession as detailed above, in addition, there may be negative cost implications on the public, which in view of the LSSA is contrary to the objectives of the LPA.

The LSSA welcomes the decision by the LPFF to urgently consider to delay the proposed implementation of the recovery of the premiums payable for PI insurance, by a year.
In addition, the LPFF advised that the portal for legal practitioners to apply for their new Fidelity Fund certificates (FFC) will be opened shortly.

The LSSA is encouraged by the stance of the LPFF to engage with the LSSA and discuss options available to the LPIIF to address its underwriting losses, so that the financial impact on legal practitioners may be reduced.

LSSA Communications:
Nomfundo Jele Tel: (012) 366 8800 or 072 402 6344


Editor’s note:

The Law Society of South Africa brings together its constituent members – the Black Lawyers Association, the National Association of Democratic Lawyers and the provincial attorneys’ associations – in representing South Africa’s 27 200 attorneys and 6 600 candidate attorneys.

Law Society congratulates Springboks on Rugby World Cup victory

The Law Society of South Africa (LSSA) would like to congratulate the Springboks in their 2019 Rugby World Cup win.

The Springboks became Rugby World Cup champions after defeating England 32-12 in Yokohama, Japan, on Saturday 2 November.

‘The Boks, led by captain, Siya Kolisi and coach, Rassie Erasmus, not only won the World Cup, but also united our country. What a beautiful sight to see our rainbow nation stand together!’ The euphoria created by the sterling performance of the Boks have brought people of different races, cultures and walks of life together and united them for a common purpose,’ says LSSA President, Mvuzo Notyesi.

He adds: ‘The whole team played exceptionally well. We would also like to congratulate Makazole Mapimpi for making history by becoming the first Springbok player to score a try in a Rugby World Cup final. We would also like to specifically mention Rassie Erasmus, who prepared the team under difficult conditions and circumstances. He demonstrated commitment to transform the rugby environment whilst focussing on talent. He focused on constitutional values, which demand equal opportunities and realising the potential of all South Africans. His ‘Coach of the Year’ award is very well deserved. We also extend our congratulations to the technical support team – operating in the background – that worked with the Springboks.’

Siya Kolisi became the third Springbok captain to lift the Webb Ellis Cup. The other two captains that led the Springboks to victory are Francois Pienaar and John Smith. This third World Cup title draws the Springboks level with the All Blacks for the most Rugby World Cup victories. Siya Kolisi is the first black captain in the world, to lead a team to a world cup victory.

‘We wish to express our gratitude to all Springbok fans across the globe for their loyal and passionate support to the team throughout the various stages of the Rugby World Cup. This is the motivation and inspiration they needed to be crowned world champions. The victory challenges all South Africans to work together for our country,’ concludes Mr Notyesi.

LSSA Communications:
Nomfundo Jele Tel: (012) 366 8800 or 072 402 6344

Editor’s note:

The Law Society of South Africa brings together its constituent members – the Black Lawyers Association, the National Association of Democratic Lawyers and the provincial attorneys’ associations – in representing South Africa’s 27 200 attorneys and 6 600 candidate