Entries by LSSA

LSSA strongly condemns disturbing personal attacks on Judge Bashier Vally and on the judiciary

The Law Society of South Africa (LSSA) once again reiterates its previous condemnation against any attack on the judiciary. In particular, we now again strongly condemn the disturbing personal attack by a branch of the ANC Youth League and by Mr Mzwanele Manyi, on Judge Bashier Vally as a result of Judge Vally’s judgment against President Zuma, in the North Gauteng High Court last week. Such unwarranted attacks appear to have the sole aim of undermining the judiciary and thereby fail to be in the interest of society.

The court ordered the President to submit the record and reasons of the decision to reshuffle his Cabinet on 31 March 2017. The LSSA has noted the announcement by President Zuma that he has filed an application for leave to appeal the decision of the court. It is the President’s right to do this.

‘It is, however, established law that executive decisions are subject to a challenge based on legality and rationality, as was conceded by the President in this matter. But even if this were not the case, we are shocked by the disturbing accusations against Judge Vally – and the judiciary in general — and regard them as an attack on the rule of law and the independence of the judiciary,’ say LSSA Co-Chairpersons Walid Brown and David Bekker.

Should they feel strongly about their convictions, the LSSA urges the complainants to submit these complaints with full grounds to the Judicial Service Commission for urgent investigation, as this is the correct body to investigate such serious allegations against a judge.

The LSSA further urges the African National Congress and Government to distance themselves from these irresponsible public statements, which in the absence of substantiated allegations, must be seen as an attack on the judiciary.

ISSUED ON BEHALF OF THE CO-CHAIRPERSONS OF THE LAW SOCIETY OF SOUTH AFRICA, WALID BROWN AND DAVID BEKKER
by the Law Society of South Africa Communication Department
Contact: Barbara Whittle, Communication Manager, barbara@LSSA.org.za  (012) 366 8800 or 083 380 1307
Nomfundo Manyathi-Jele, Communications Officer, nomfundom@LSSA.org.za  Tel: (012) 366 8800 or 072 402 6344.


Editor’s note:

The Law Society of South Africa brings together its six constituent members – the Cape Law Society, the KwaZulu-Natal Law Society, the Law Society of the Free State, the Law Society of the Northern Provinces, the Black Lawyers Association and the National Association of Democratic Lawyers – in representing South Africa’s 25 200 attorneys and 5 700 candidate attorneys.

 

LSSA urges Judicial Service Commission to scrutinise judicial candidates for racist tendencies

The Law Society of South Africa (LSSA) notes the resignation of High Court Judge Mabel Jansen, as announced by the Department of Justice and Constitutional Development yesterday. The now infamous comments by Judge Jansen on social media have been correctly condemned in all sectors of our society.

The LSSA once again condemns any form of racism in our society and particularly within the judiciary. As a profession and a country we rightly look upon our independent judiciary with pride.

However, there is no place for any undercurrent of racism in judges appointed to the Bench. In this regard the recent revelations at the Judicial Service Commission (JSC) interviews about alleged institutional racism in some of our courts, are also noted. Should these allegations be based on any semblance of fact, it is also condemned unconditionally.
 

In this regard the LSSA encourages the JSC to continue interrogating any potential judicial appointees on any history of racist tendencies. In order for us to move forward as a society we need to start respecting each individual as an equal, as enshrined in our Constitution.

ISSUED ON BEHALF OF THE CO-CHAIRPERSONS OF THE LAW SOCIETY OF SOUTH AFRICA, WALID BROWN AND DAVID BEKKER
by the Law Society of South Africa Communication Department
Tel: (012) 366 8800 or website: www.LSSA.org.za
Contact:
Barbara Whittle, Communication Manager 083 380 1307; barbara@LSSA.org.za
Nomfundo Manyathi-Jele, Communications Officer 072 402 6344; nomfundom@LSSA.org.za

 

Placing the blame for medical malpractice suits at the door of attorneys will not lead to the improvement of the standard of public health care for the majority in South Africa

The Council of The Cape Law Society has noted with grave concern the recent report in the Daily Dispatch where MEC Belinda Francis Scott is quoted, inter alia, as saying that attorneys are “not only criminal, but parasitical. They are vultures”.

There appears to be an unfortunate tendency, by the Minister and some of the MEC’s responsible for health, of avoiding responsibility for the weaknesses in their Departments, by deflecting public attention away from these weaknesses and focusing attention on the contingent liability claims against their Departments, coupled with the suggestion that attorneys manufacture these claims against the State, which results in a budgetary crisis. No mention is made of the poor service that the majority of the population is subjected to daily in the public health facilities of South Africa, which ultimately gives rise to such claims.

It is not constructive, is unhelpful and is in fact a disservice to the majority of the public who rely on these services to overlook the symptoms of a dysfunctional public health service in South Africa and to instead blame attorneys for those symptoms. A person who believes that he/she has suffered damages as a result of medical negligence is entitled to be advised and represented by an independent attorney, to have his/her matter determined in a fair public hearing before a court and if so determined by a court, to receive compensation. The same right to approach courts to enforce rights is exercised regularly by public officials whenever they wish to assert certain rights or defend themselves against claims of various natures. The Department is plainly not in a position to assist a person who has been injured and suffered damages as this would give rise to a clear conflict of interest.

Attorneys promote the right to access to justice that is enshrined in Section 34 of the Bill of Rights. They help members of the public, who may sometimes be impecunious, to take cases to court where the judiciary determines the merits of each case without fear, favour or prejudice. They do this consistent with their oath of office (see Schedule 2, Item 6 (1) of the Constitution).

It is of great concern that some political leaders responsible for health have expressed the view that users of public sector health care facilities should be denied their constitutional right of access to justice. In all medical negligence cases, the Department of Health is legally represented. Where the Department loses cases brought against it, its lawyers ought not to be victimised, as they cannot be expected to undo the negligence that health care professionals visit on those members of the public who place their lives in the hands of health care professionals.

The Department of Health should respect the right of all South Africans to access to quality health care as enshrined in Section 27(1)(a) of the Bill of Rights and must respect the dignity of all the people of South Africa as enshrined in Section 10 of the Bill of Rights.

The Cape Law Society calls on those political leaders responsible for health to refrain from making unfair generalisations and ill considered public pronouncements that are calculated to tarnish the image of the legal profession in South Africa. Such antics are not constructive.
Those political leaders responsible for health who are unable to ensure that the majority of the people of South Africa receive the high quality health services they deserve, should do the responsible thing and resign as soon as possible.

The Cape Law Society believes that an improved understanding can be enhanced through dialogue and extends an invitation to political leaders responsible for health to engage in constructive discussions with the organised legal profession in the spirit of working together. Furthermore, The Cape Law Society will not hesitate to take action against any attorney found to have acted unprofessionally by touting for work at hospitals. The Department is encouraged to report any such instances to The Cape Law Society.

Issued by
Lulama Lobi
Acting President of The Cape Law Society
Issued on behalf of the Council of the Cape Law Society

24 April 2017
The Cape Law Society
Tel: (021) 443 6700„ Fax: (021) 443 6751/2„ Email: cls@capelawsoc.law.za„ 
Website: www.capelawsoc.law.za
 

LSSA calls on Council on Higher Education to consult the legal profession on issues related to the LLB degree

The Law Society of South Africa (LSSA) questions the decision by the Council on Higher Education (CHE) not to include the legal profession in its review of the LLB degree.

The CHE has recently published the outcomes of its review of the LLB degree, on 12 April 2017. The LSSA has invited the CHE to consult the legal profession on issues relating to the LLB curriculum. Also, it has offered its support and its commitment to law faculties which may require input and assistance from the attorneys’ profession to ensure their LLB degrees achieve full accreditation by the CHE.

‘We deem it critical to the attorneys’ profession to ensure that law graduates are effectively prepared to enter the profession and to serve the public professionally and efficiently. It is also critical that law students currently in the system are assured of the relevance and practicality of their degrees,’ say LSSA Co-Chairpersons Walid Brown and David Bekker.

Although the LSSA was asked for input in the standards-drafting process aspect of the review, it expresses serious concerns that it has not been consulted on the process since 2015. ‘The legal profession is a material stakeholder and represents the largest group of employers of law graduates, with up to 60% of law graduates joining the attorneys’ profession,’ say Mr Brown and Mr Bekker.

The LSSA, together with the South Africa Law Deans Association and the General Council of the Bar of South Africa, initiated the LLB review process following a summit they hosted on the LLB degree, held on 29 May 2013. This was after concern was expressed at the skills gap presented by law gradates when entering the legal profession. Following that summit, the stakeholders resolved to request the CHE to conduct a standard-setting process for the LLB degree. In conducting this exercise, the CHE was requested to consult widely with the LLB Summit Steering Committee of the profession established after the summit.

Mr Brown and Mr Bekker note: ‘It is accordingly difficult to understand how the profession can be sidelined by the CHE at this critical juncture in the process.’

ISSUED ON BEHALF OF THE CO-CHAIRPERSONS OF THE LAW SOCIETY OF SOUTH AFRICA, WALID BROWN AND DAVID BEKKER
by the Law Society of South Africa Communication Department
Contact: Barbara Whittle, Communication Manager, barbara@LSSA.org.za (012) 366 8800 or 083 380 1307
Nomfundo Manyathi-Jele, Communications Officer, nomfundom@LSSA.org.za Tel: (012) 366 8800 or 072 402 6344.

 

New Co-Chairpersons Walid Brown and David Bekker lead Law Society of South Africa at time of transformation and change to new dispensation

Cape Town attorney Walid Brown (right) and Harrismith attorney David Bekker were elected Co-Chairpersons of the Law Society of South Africa (LSSA) at its annual general meeting on 22 April 2017.

Mr Brown says his objective for the coming year will be to utilise the momentum of transforming the legal profession, through the Legal Practice Act, to implement structures that will lead to a change in the demographics of this profession, a change in the power dynamic within the profession and ultimately to a more equal wealth distribution amongst the lawyers of this country. ’However, within this context it will always be necessary for us to ensure that we maintain a culture of excellence as a profession in whatever we do,’ he stresses.

Similarly, Mr Bekker notes that a smooth transfer to the Legal Practice Council and the continued existence of a representative body for all legal practitioners are important. ‘I would also like to get young practitioners more involved in professional affairs, as well as enhance mediation and arbitration by attorneys,’ he says.

The Legal Practice Act 28 of 2014 is expected to be fully implemented in 2018, bringing the Legal Practice Council – the new, national regulatory body for attorneys and advocates – into effect.
About the Co-Chairpersons
Walid Brown is a director at the Cape Town office of Werksmans Attorneys where he focuses on litigation and dispute resolution as well as insolvency, business rescue and restructuring.
He has the BA (UCT) and LLB (UWC) degrees as well as an Advanced Certificate in Insolvency Litigation (UP) and a Certificate in Advanced Business Rescue (UNISA).
He is an executive member of the Western Cape Branch of the Black Lawyers Association (BLA) and has represented the BLA on the LSSA Council since 2016.
David Bekker is serving his second term as Co-Chairperson, having been Co-Chairperson for the period 2013/2014.
Mr Bekker has been an attorney for 40 years this year having been admitted as an attorney and conveyancer in 1977 after having competed the BIur degree at the University of the Free State. He practiced for his own account until he joined Cloete & Neveling in 1982.

Mr Bekker has been a Council member of the LSSA since 2009 and has been a member of its Management Committee since 2010. He is currently chairperson of the LSSA’s Financial Intelligence Centre Act Committee; serves on the Deceased Estates, Trusts and Planning Committee and Competition Committee; and has been a trustee of the Legal Provident Fund since April 2009.

At international level, Mr Bekker represents the LSSA on the Council of the Commonwealth Lawyers Association. At provincial level, Mr Bekker has been a Council member of the Law Society of the Free State since 1989 and was its President from 1994 to 1996.

ISSUED ON BEHALF OF THE CO-CHAIRPERSONS OF THE LAW SOCIETY OF SOUTH AFRICA, WALID BROWN AND DAVID BEKKER
by the Law Society of South Africa Communication Department
Barbara Whittle, Communication Manager, (012) 366 8800 or 083 380 1307; barbara@LSSA.org.za
Nomfundo Manyathi-Jele, Communications Officer, (012) 366 8800 or 072 402 6344; nomfundom@LSSA.org.za